title is self-explanitory. i will try to type out my family tree, but it will sort of fail.
The Rommeleys
Mary Rommeley-Francie’s grandmother, Katie’s mother. A saint. The main soruce of advice aboout the upbringing of Katie’s children. She was the one who told Katir to read them a page of Shakespeare and the Bible every night, and to keep a tin can bank nailed to the floor for saving up to buy a piece of land
Thomas Rommeley-Wanted kids to stay unmarried and work to make money for him. Cruel, intolerant, racist, speaks only German.
Their children:
Sissy-Oldest Rommeley child. I think one of my favorite characters in the book so far. What today we would call a slut, to put it blatently. sleeps with many men and calls them all John. Had ten futile births. A “slut” but the most tender, loving, motherly person one would ever meet. Brings up a lot of issues of polarization and labels.
Eliza-was not pretty or interested in life so went to a convent that she wasn’t allowed to leave except when her dad died to go to his funeral. the story told is that francie wanted to be a nun, until, when she was smaller, she saw Eliza at Thomas’ funeral and decided that she did not want to be a nun because Eliza had hairs growing off of her chin, and Francie thought that was what nunhood entailed XD.
Evy-married to Willie the horseman, who is basically a goofy screw-up, but he plays guitar, so she was like *sigh*. They have 3 children. She really wanted the children to learn music. Rommeley women love musicians.
Katie-stops working in her clothing factory to marry Johnny. they begin working at a public school as the janitors. This is the happiest point in their lives. Katie is Francie and Neely’s mother.
The Nolans-
Ruthie Nolan-she and her husband are froom Ireland
Mickie Nolan-dies shortly after his first child’s birth
All of their cihldren were handsome, musical boys:
Andy-Oldest, handsomest, died of consumption, had an epic “sickness pillow” that Georgie and Frankie puchased.
Georgie-died in drunkie freak accident.
Frankie-also died but i don’t remember how
Johnny-Francie’s dad. A bit of a drunk, though charming. Fell in love with and married Katie.
Then the next generation
Francie Nolan-The protagonist
Neely-Francie’s brother. Born a stronger baby than Francie but doesn’t become one.
The section of reading we did was mostly a family tree. It says at the end the part where it constructs a family tree something along the lines of “Francie was all of the Rommeleys and all of the Nolans”. It also says that the difference between Katie and Johnny is that they both know their lives are over, but Katie refuses to accept it and she perseveres.
It also outlines the part of Johnny and Katie’s life up until this point. They were janitors at a school at night during the happiest part of their lives. Johnny lost them the job, though, the night that Katie gave birth to Francie. He went out drinking instead of tending to the school. I see this passage as the part when Johnny’s drinking really starts to rolls downhill. It oulines Neely’s birth and Katie’s thoughts that she will love this stronger baby better, but she mustn’t let Francie know this. During chapter 11, Katie tries to get Sissy to help with Johnny’s drinking problem, and she lies with him all night and tends to him like a baby. During this chapter, it is said that Sissy’s ttwo great fails are that she’s a great mother and a great lover. I think the two are related and that Sissy excellent at both simply because she has so much love inside her. sissy has a tendancy to make everyone around her happy. after sissy tends to him, katie inquires as to whether they’ve slept together, and sissy makes it apparent that they haven’t, but she tells katie not to nag him. in the 12th chapter, they move apartments because katie is so embarassed by johnny’s drunken wailing that keeps all of the neighbors up. I think that the family tree buisness will serve as some sort of forshadowing. For example, in one part it says that all of the Rommeley women love men who are musical. I think this will play out either in Francie falling for a boy who is musical or will explain her great love for her father. Also, now her love of her father more than her mother sort of makes sense seeing as her mother loves Neely more.
This book as a historical source-
The gender roles of the time period, i believe, are acknowledged in this book, but not exemplified. The book, with it’s sort of…accepting…i guess…nature, sort of defies some of the set roles of the times. For example, it is acknowledged in multiple places that Sissy is often called a “bad girl” for her sexual exploits, but it draws a rather clear connection between her promiscuous behavior and her nurturing, motherly side. Also, there is a part when Johnny wonders to himself how someone who is a “bad” girl can be so good.
Also, emma pointed this out yesterday after we looked at the pictures from the depression. Women have always been interpretted as being “the weaker sex” or what have you, but in all of the pictures from the photo essay of the depression, the stronger people are predominantly the woman, by far. They are holding their children while walking for miles, preparing food, etc., and the men in this same photo essay repeatedly look like they are giving up. In a tree grows in Brooklyn, it bluntly says that the Nolan men were very weak and a dying breed and that the Rommeley women were all very strong people (think “I will survive” XD). I don’t know whether this means that the book reflects the reality of gender in that era, whether it defies it, or whether both the author of the photo essay and the author of a tree grows in brooklyn are just biased because they’re both opressed women, or something.
I also noticed the topic of homogenization come up. Thomas Rommely spoke only German and Mary was bilingual, i believe, in German and English and she wanted her kids not to be able to speak any German so that they could a. have the same opportunities as all of the other kids b. not be able to speak to their verbally abusive, racist father. She sent them to a school that taught only English so that their culture would be drowned out. I noticed this is particular because we’d been talking about immigrant assimilation and opportunities.
Family roles were also different then. Both Thomas Rommeley and Ruthie Nolan wanted their children not to marry and instead to work and make money for the parents. I thought this was interesting, because it shows a bit of a change between then and now.
This book gives a good sense of the cost of things then. I was at first sort of pissed, honestly, at how it felt a little like a historical textbook because it had all of these references of how much stuff costed, and what exactly they wore and the names of it, that it was obvious it wasn’t written in the actual time period. As Emma pointed out though, it’s really just trying to set a mood and setting. I realized that it must have been written in this time period for a reason. Anyway, it does give a fairly good sense of how much things cost, because rationing money is a large part of the Rommeley/Nolan household. For example, the midwife charges 25 cents, which is sort of a lot. also Mary describes how much money you would have saved in coal by not burning it for an hour as 3 cents. also, in their janatorial job, i beleive katie and johnny make about $50 a month, which is considered quite a good deal for people of their class. I was baffled as to why a night custodial shift paid so much XD.
alright if i come up with anything else, i’ll post it as a comment on this. peace. *ps, i fixed the eratic spacing